$62,006, $1.91 billion, 2.75x: CZ says he’s been buying these past few days; OKX’s Star Xu says he’s lying—so who’s telling the truth in this war of words?
#CZ The most interesting moment in this latest sell-off wasn’t the price action—it was two exchange founders publicly falling out on X. Late last night and into the early hours of today, CZ posted first, then Star Xu came in swinging in the replies. Teng also weighed in with data today. Three people, three different stories, and only one thing is certain: Bitcoin (
$BTC ) fell to a low of $62,006 on November 15, down about 15% in 11 days.
CZ’s post began with a ground rule: no one can say for sure why prices are falling, and correlation doesn’t imply causation. He then listed some possible reasons: money may have been pulled into Anthropic’s IPO (which is set to go public on November 19, with up to about $64.4 billion to be raised); U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs saw roughly $1.91 billion in outflows over seven trading days; security incidents may have spooked some investors; and there’s pressure from inflation and U.S. Treasuries. The key was in his final two lines: Binance hasn’t sold any coins, and he received some stablecoins over the past few days and has already bought in. He even joked that maybe the market was falling because he bought. For context, CZ has not been Binance’s CEO since November 2023. Teng and He Yi are now co-CEOs, and this post was a personal statement, not a company announcement.
Star Xu wasn’t buying it. He questioned the truth of CZ’s claims and accused Binance and CZ of being involved in the massive sell-offs in October for two years in a row. But so far, he hasn’t posted a single on-chain transaction record to back that up. CZ hasn’t shared any purchase transaction hashes either. The two are making plenty of noise, but neither has offered any evidence so far.
Teng weighed in today too, posting a study that showed a certain USD-denominated platform’s net selling was 2.75 times Binance’s—implying that if we’re talking about who’s selling, Binance wasn’t the biggest seller. But there’s an important distinction here: an exchange’s proof of reserves can show that customer assets are fully backed, but it doesn’t prove that the exchange hasn’t moved its own coins. Conversely, saying “they’re lying” without transaction records to support it is just an accusation, not a conclusion.
The twist is that the price has already moved on: after hitting a low of $62,006, Bitcoin bounced back above $64,500, up about 4.2%. ETF outflows are also slowing; last Friday’s daily outflows were about 35% lower than the day before. The argument can continue, but the money hasn’t waited for them to settle it.
My take is that the war of words itself is more interesting than the conclusion. CZ chose to publicly say he was buying near $62,006, a new low since July, to send a message of confidence to the market. Star Xu chose to attack him the same day to seize the narrative over “who’s dumping.” Until either side provides on-chain evidence, only two things would change my mind: one of them posting a verifiable transaction hash, or ETF flows actually turning positive. Otherwise, this is just a shouting match with no referee. Watch if you like, but don’t pick a side and trade on it.
Whose side are you on? A: Trust CZ—Binance really hasn’t sold, and he bought near the low. B: Trust Star Xu—you can’t take everything at face value; wait for on-chain evidence. I’ll post a reconciliation as soon as someone shares verifiable transaction records.
—Baobao @ Binance Square