Metaplanet Buys Back 7.1% of Its Shares in Two Weeks: No Bitcoin Bought, Yet Bitcoin Per Share Still Went Up?
Last night, we talked about Strategy selling stock to buy Bitcoin. Today, this Japanese Bitcoin treasury company is doing the opposite: buying back its own shares.
The source: Metaplanet CEOâs own post on X (7:06 p.m. Beijing time, November 2, quoting the companyâs âShare Buyback Progress Announcementâ):
1. From October 14 to 31, the company bought back 96,447,400 shares, about 7.1% of its outstanding shares.
2. It spent a total of 25.27 billion yen. Do the math using those two figures, and the average price comes to about 262 yen per share.
3. Future capital allocation will âfocus on maximizing Bitcoin per share,â taking into account the share price, mNAV, and market conditions.
Why can a buyback increase âBitcoin per shareâ?
· Bitcoin per share = Bitcoin held by the company ÷ number of shares outstanding.
· If the numerator stays the same and the denominator falls by about 7.1%, Bitcoin per share increases by about 7.6%. This assumes the amount of Bitcoin held stays unchanged and the repurchased shares are no longer counted as outstanding.
· Roughly speaking, mNAV means âthe companyâs market cap Ă· the value of its Bitcoin holdings.â The usual argument goes: when itâs above 1, issuing shares to buy Bitcoin is more worthwhile; when itâs near or below 1, buying back shares may be âcheaper.â Thatâs the logic, not my take on its share price.
A few points to keep in mind:
· Buybacks take real money. The CEOâs post doesnât go into where the funds came from or whether this will affect future Bitcoin purchases, so I wonât make anything up.
· I couldnât verify the figures circulating online about âsats per share rising from X to Yâ in the companyâs original announcement, so Iâm leaving them out.
· One company sells shares to buy Bitcoin; another buys back shares. Both are talking about âBitcoin per share,â but using opposite approaches.
To put it bluntly: people who only care about âhow many more coins were boughtâ will scroll right past this news. But for shareholders, fewer shares and more Bitcoin can have a similar effect on paper.
Which approach do you think is more prudent: issuing shares to buy Bitcoin, or buying back shares?
$BTC #Metaplanet #Explainer